Snakebites in the Americas: a Neglected Problem in Public Health

Most Common Types of Snakes and Their Classification in the Americas and by Region

Venomous snakes belong to the Viperidae family, and two of its subfamilies are the most important and abundant in the region (Americas): coral and pit vipers (Crotalinae).

Coral snakes include two genera of snakes: Micrurus and Micruroides that are found from the Southeastern USA to Central Argentina, with a capacity to live in a variety of habitats from extremely dry areas to forests and savannas. Micrurus has been reported only in Central America (Table 1) [9, 13•].

Table 1 Frequent snake species causing envenomation in the Americas

About 120 species and subspecies have been identified in the Americas from both genus [9].

Morbidity and Mortality of Snakebites in the Americas

Snakebites occur frequently in the Americas, especially in rural areas and wilderness/sylvatic areas where human and snakes overlap their habitats. True to their designation as neglected tropical disease snakebites are under-reported [1, 11, 19, 20]. Brazil, Costa Rica, the USA, and Colombia have a more abundant literature than other countries in the region. However, most countries produce sporadic publications of clinical cases, case series, and in some cases, the use of traditional treatment. Most of the time, these publications, unfortunately, do not make it to the countries’ official reports. However, in all countries, snakebites are a serious medical concern [1, 14].

Snakebites—or ophidic accidents as they are frequently called in the Americas—are a health event occurring periodically especially in rural areas where human dwellings and snake habitats overlap. Most reports agree that the most important barriers to prompt treatment are geographical distance to a health care center as well as cultural beliefs [1, 11•]. Empirical observation generations have led local population to use as first resource plant products without a scientific validation. Studies done in Central America showed that farmers because of their work practices expose themselves to bites and tend to underestimate the severity of snakebites and start treating them with products available in their locality: plants and ointments from animal tissues, and only when the condition of the victim worsen, they try to reach a health clinic; all the process delays an effective treatment with access to antivenom and increases the risk of mortality [8, 14, 20].

Annually, there are approximately 57,500 snakebites (annual incidence 6.2 per 100,000 population) in the region, with around 370 deaths (0.04 per 100,000 population) [1]. Due to the issues mentioned above, these figures do not reflect the true occurrence of snakebites. Table 2 shows the overall number of cases for the Americas.

Table 2 Snakebites in the Americas with epidemiological indicators for 2017

As mentioned earlier, Brazil reports most cases in the Americas, outnumbering, due to its population size and geography, the number of cases reported by the rest of the American and Caribbean countries [1, 21,22,23]. Despite its greater number of cases, it is important to highlight that the reported snakebite case fatality rate (CFR) was lower for Brazil.

According to data published by Chippaux [1], the countries with higher incidence of snakebites per 100,000 inhabitants were Panama, Guyana, French Guiana, Venezuela, Costa Rica, Nicaragua, and Brazil. French Guiana and Guyana had the highest mortality, and the case fatality rate was higher in Bolivia (4%) and French Guiana (3%).

For Central America, publications were obtained for six out of the seven countries with Belize being the exception. No gray literature was found for Belize either. In Central America, only three countries Panama, Costa Rica, and Panama reported mortality. The CFR was lower in Panama (0.79) than in the other two reporting countries (Costa Rica and Nicaragua) with 1.0 AND 1.08, respectively [1].

Epidemiology and Clinical Manifestation of Snakebites in Different Countries

Different studies were reviewed from the America countries. Most studies reported cases from specific regions or ecological areas in these countries, and they may not represent the different ecosystems or human settled areas of the whole country.

The following is a brief account of the epidemiological situation of snakebites in selected countries.

El Salvador. A study in El Salvador from 2014 to 2019 identified five deaths and found that snakebite incidents increased in the rainy season affecting people of ages between 10 and 30 years and with a male:female ratio of 1.5:1.0; this study showed a higher occurrence of snakebites in males, due to greater occupational exposure [24]. These findings are consistent with Brazilian reports and explicitly confirm this characterization [23, 25]. They also stress the importance of climate factors and increased human activity in the fieldwork (agriculture) affecting mostly agriculture population. Increased population of both humans and snakes is also important drivers of snakebite incidents [25].

USA. Warpinski [26] in the USA identified that patients suffering bites by crotaline snakes suffer local tissue damages, coagulopathies, circulatory collapse, and anaphylactic reactions. On the other hand, the other common envenomation in the USA is caused by coral snakes, which produce neurotoxicity but with low incidence [27, 28] and its occurrence identify snakebites as an occupational risk associated with landscaping and direct work with snakes. Envenomation in the upper extremities was the most frequent in this study and resulted from unintentional interactions.

Greene [28] studied the snakebites of members of the family Micrurus (coral snakes) in Texas and the management of neurological effects, pain, and inflammation. Severe manifestations such as respiratory dysfunction or skeletal paralysis were not identified. No antivenom was necessary but it was available.

Baumgartner [29] identified the copperhead (Agkistrodon contortrix) as another important snake as cause of envenomation in the Midwest state of MO. In this case, the treatment was given with antivenom; patients required 17–28 days for total recovery. Adverse reactions to the antivenom such as pruritus and hypersensitivity were also documented.

Honduras. Studies done in three different Honduran hospitals were found. Altogether, they report 120 cases in recent years and showed that the age range for those affected by snakebites was quite broad, from 1 to 75 years (average 26). More than half (55%) of patients were male, 86% were of rural residence, and most had only attended primary school. The patient occupations included farmers, students, and housewives. The average hospital stay for this case series was 2.5 days. An additional report from a tertiary hospital included 1120 cases with similar demographic information [30,31,32]. The snake responsible in these incidents was mainly Bothrops atrox (locally called Barba amarilla), although many victims were not able to identify the type of snake attacking them [30,31,32].

An additional Honduran study was done for a thesis project by Ponce Arellana [33] in a pediatric population from 3 to 17 years (n = 24) identifying symptoms like pain, edema, and reddening of affected area, a period of 3 h between the bite and the access to medical care of 4 h which is a critical time for the initial symptoms. This study included information on alteration in the gastrointestinal tract and hematological changes. Children were left with areas of disfiguration in legs and arms, which affect the functionality of the limbs as children grow up.

Another Honduran publication by Urbina from a study involving 28 hospitals and 1120 patients indicated that the most common clinical manifestations were compartmental syndromes (in 53% cases) and acute renal failure (7.7% cases) [34]. Other symptoms included neurological changes (motricity or sensibility) in 50% of cases. Local inflammation and edema were also observed in 86% patients around venom inoculation in [34].

A paper written in 2011 by Aleman [35] used key informants in Western Honduras, and through the interviews, he identified the presence of snakes in areas of agricultural activity with the occurrence of snakebites to humans and cattle, resulting in mortality of three farmers according to the informants. This paper described the activity of Crotalus durissus in the study area as well as of Bothrops atrox.

Venezuela. Two reports published in local university journals identified the period of June to December as the most active time for snakebites, mostly caused by Bothrops species, Crotalus, and Lachesis. They also documented the time elapse from snakebite to medical attention was 6 h or more [36, 37].

Mexico. Mexican authors have described the events of snakebites and the time of stay in the hospital as 10 days [38,39].

Colombia. With regard to Colombia, we identified three publications that added blisters and tissue necrosis to the symptoms caused by Bothrops snakes: Most snakebite victims reported in these studies in Colombia were people of African ancestry. The peak of event occurrence was during the rainy season and in the periods of agricultural products harvest [40,41,42].

Costa Rica. Costa Rican publications by Avila Aguero [43] and Lomonte [44] described that for the snakebite victims, the media of hospital stay was around 12.8 days and the time to get access to medical care and antivenoms was less than a day. Three young patients died of hemodynamic disorders, and secondary infections were reported as complications. Accessibility was described as a problem delaying the arrival of patients to health care and increasing the risk of complications.

Brazil. Brazil was the country with most publications in either University or Research Foundation journals. They described the mean time to reach medical care as 4 h and administration of antivenoms in 6 h. Vieira Tavares [25] analyzed 3019 cases occurring between 22007 and 2014 and found as the mean time to reach medical facilities was 3 or more hours. This author reports 13 deaths in that cohort [21,22,23].

Martinique and French Guyana. Ressiere et al. [45] did a study in Martinique and French Guyana and reported the role of Bothrops lanceolatus in the snakebites and mentioned as the most important manifestations: thrombotic effects and local tissue damage.

Ecuador. Praba Egge [46] did a study in Ecuador and reported that her sample of 142 patients had as a mean of stay in the hospital 4.3 days, 90% of they recovered, 8% suffer of abscessed post-treatment, and a mortality of 2.9% occurred because of complications such as renal failure, respiratory failure, and disseminated intravascular coagulation.

Panama. Pecchio [47] studied the clinical files of 390 patients in Panama who suffered snakebites caused by Bothrops asper and went for medical treatment with 25% of them arriving 6 or more hours after the event. Fifty-five percent received therapy with antivenom and 67% a dose of tetanus toxoid.

Uruguay. This country reports only cases of envenoming with Bothrops snakes, but they have also papers documenting written about envenoming with a Micrurus. One case was documented by Juanena in 2018 [48] which is relevant for the neurological manifestations.

The different studies included in our review mention the aspect of access as a barrier to appropriate and opportune treatment. An area to study is the mechanisms to increase accessibility to antivenoms in the different countries to reduce morbidity and mortality. An open question is the frequency and results of the natural treatments; some studies have been done without a final conclusive result but stating the need to explore these area [49•, 50•].

留言 (0)

沒有登入
gif