Intuitions and heuristics can be sources of adaptive decision strategies in emergency care.

The professional cultures of nurses and medical doctors influence clinicians’ use of intuitive sense-making.

Leadership and non-clinical heuristics are rarely studied and present new frontiers for research.

Across a range of fields, including healthcare, heuristics are typically conceived as a source of bias and systematic error. However, research across the psychological and management sciences shows that intuition and heuristics are also vital sources of adaptive decision strategies, especially in complex, uncertain environments. The complexity of the emergency care environment marks this environment as one in which non-clinical intuitions and heuristics are likely to emerge and function as adaptive decision strategies. The aim of this study was to map and contextualize what is known about leadership and non-clinical intuitions and heuristics in emergency care.

Based on a systematic search of the Pubmed, Scopus, Web of Science, MEDLINE and CINAHL electronic databases, we conducted a scoping review to map what is known about leadership and non-clinical intuitions and adaptive heuristics in emergency care.

Of the 1219 articles retrieved, 9 met the inclusion criteria. Our review revealed four key findings. First, intuitions are used to make judgments about patients, caring for patients, and coordinating with colleagues. Second, although non-clinical intuitions are documented, non-clinical heuristics are rarely studied. Third, the literature is focused on nurses and silent on the use of non-clinical intuition and heuristics among medical doctors. Finally, professional cultures influence clinicians’ use of intuitive sense- and decision-making.

This review highlights the dearth of research into non-clinical intuitions and heuristics in emergency care. Understood in the context of insights from the psychological and management sciences about intuitions and ‘smart’ heuristics as adaptive decision strategies, our findings point to new frontiers of research into leadership in emergency care.

© 2023 The Author(s). Published by Elsevier Ltd.